It would be a very interesting experiment to watch a group of people read “Mrs. Kelly’s Monster” behind a two-way mirror. To be a witness to the vast array of facial expressions that would occur would be fascinating to me.
However, if someone would have recorded my face from the time I started reading the article until the end, I would make sure to burn that tape. I can only imagine the range of expression I would have emoted for my audience.
When a piece of writing is capable of making the reader physically feel uneasy or anxious, that’s when the writer knows he or she simply hasn’t told a story. The writer has made the reader part of the journey in the writing.
It is obvious why Jon Franklin won the Pulitzer Prize for this piece. He did not miss a single opportunity for description, most especially with his brilliant use of capturing the sounds of the operating room.
When he describes the loudspeaker that produces an audible popping sound with “the steady pop, pop, popping,” my own heart began to “pop” in the same rhythm every time he brought that onomatopoeia back into the story. In addition, the electrical “bzzzzt as he burns the bleeder closed” forced me to clench my fist and scrunch my face as though I had experienced the physcial pain caused by the action.
Along with the sounds, Frankin’s use of the time throughout the story creates a great sense of urgency and anxiety. It is interesting to think a trinket that goes “tick, tock” can have an enormous effect on people’s lives. But if one stops and thinks about it, some of the most stressful occurrences of everyday life result from looking at a clock.
When people look at clocks and realize they are late, they stress out. When students are taking a test and realize they only have five minutes left and still have several questions to answer, they stress out. When a person has trouble sleeping at night and continues watching the clock, he or she stresses out. In this story, the doctors and assistants knew they did not have much time to complete the surgery before Mrs. Kelly’s heart would fail, and they, too, could not handle the pressure.
The use of time also allowed the reader to understand the delicate pace the doctors and assistants were going. In between each new time announced, very little movement had occurred in the procedure.
When the procedure failed, I felt as though I was actually sitting with Dr. Drucker as he bit grimly into his peanut butter sandwich. In fact, I actually got up from my chair and made myself a peanut butter sandwich. Because I felt I had shared that experience with him in the operating room, I thought it was appropriate to share in our defeat together.



